DreamWorks Shrek 2 Remastered Review – Low Aspyrations

Around twenty years ago now, I brought my friend over to my house to play games on my PlayStation 2. I owned a few that had co-op or multiplayer that he did not. There was Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (a terrible game), Looney Tunes: Space Race (a terrible game), and, of course, Shrek 2, which was… okay. A simple and short four-character brawler that wasn’t frustrating and had a lot of variety. That was enough for it to become a fond memory for me and many others I know who played it when they were younger. On that day, as we were fighting the final boss, we spilled cola on the console. I was devastated. The PlayStation 2 did not recover for years, and I had to go back to PlayStation 1. Somehow, while playing through DreamWorks Shrek 2 Remastered, I felt worse than I did on that day.

Out of the companies currently working in the retro port and/or remaster field, Aspyr Media is certainly one of them. They don’t exactly have the most consistent track record, releasing either solid ports with upgraded graphics or not-great-looking ones that introduce a slew of new problems to titles that were previously working perfectly fine, or otherwise already saw fan-developed fixes. It’s been years since their most infamous work (though perhaps the yet-unreleased Deus Ex Remastered could take the cake just based on trailer reactions), yet the consistency still isn’t there. Unfortunately, this is one of their new low points.

A lush green swamp
Shrek’s swamp looks so lush, no wonder everyone wants to live here!

I think a good starting point would be posing a question: how does one remaster an often purposefully unpleasant game? The franchise that is Shrek revels in fart jokes and disgusting imagery, so I don’t think it’s a stretch to say that the grimy, washed-out environments and unflattering character portrait angles of the original were an intentional choice. Perhaps one way would be to use more film grain to keep it fuzzy, and try to keep the lighting dimmer than your usual remaster.

For Aspyr, the answer is to make it brighter to fit the realistic lighting, redo all the portraits into clean, smiling shots, and add better reflections. All of this does make for “better graphics,” but immediately we forgo the identity of the game and the franchise. This is an overwhelmingly clean game about burps and farts. And the team added a photo mode to better revel in all their changes.

Shrek sitting, looking down with an open mouth
I suppose the photo mode is a way of banking on Shrek’s more recent, cursed reputation

The biggest victims are undoubtedly the character models. Somehow, even in all the grime of the Shrek universe, they still look bizarre! Even though I kind of got over the initial trailer, which definitely sent a shock through my system, it was the moment I saw Red Riding Hood (here known as Lil’ Red) when it all came back. Those huge eyes look crazy! The best way I can describe these new models is that they do look cleaned up, yes, but also stretched. Like they were based on the footage of the game running on the wrong aspect ratio. Most features are too big; a few are too small. Sometimes, the new models will clip through environments or items.

Although, to put it lightly, the new visuals weren’t to my liking, the amount of differences made me think the rest of the game could have received some big overhauls to make what was once an okay experience into something more. I quickly learned that aside from the looks, the game feels like a terribly amateurish port of the Shrek 2: Team Action PC version from 2004.

Lil' Red looking straight at the camera with open eyes
Lil’ Red was a wake up call for me to contemplate life

How else would I call mistakes like the messed-up physics? The amount of broken attacks, moments of companions getting stuck on flat terrain, and other bizarre interactions caused by this is staggering. From jumping fish encountered halfway through the game moving at lightning speeds to Fairy Godmother’s very final attack of the game being undodgeable due to its new, faster speed, it’s a disastrous showing that should never have made it to the final release. Something you see all the time trying to play old games on new machines that makes the game feel like it’s just running a shiny filter over the old version.

Shrek 2 was never the greatest game of its time, not even on the licensed side, but like most licensed games from the time, it was a formative experience for a lot of people. That’s why it was chosen for this project. You may remember the Far Far Away level where hitting pedestrians results in a GTA-style wanted level (very timely), or Jack and Jill’s farm where you could play minigames with and against your friend in co-op. Hearing the mirror proclaim “Hero Time!” and getting to see who gets to play the final bit of the level instilled a bit of rivalry into the experience. And you could always pass the controller, of course.

Pedestrians piling on top of a bench in the Far Far Away level, two GTA-style stars in the top left
During the Far Far Away level, the pedestrians would often casually fall through the world—could this a reference to the state of the GTA Trilogy launch?

I played several collections and remasters of my childhood games this year. Rugrats: Retro Rewind Collection had a few emulation issues, but it was successful at making me remember why I replayed these games all the time. Digital Eclipse started working on licensed game ports this year, and aside from their usual excellent care for filters and gameplay preservation, their featurettes from Toy Story: Retro Roundup made a lot of the games more enjoyable. Their remaster of Toy Story 3 brought the console-exclusive features on PC for the first time, and even a few crashes could not spoil my fun there. This could have been so much more.

With Shrek 2 Remastered, I think you get a strictly worse version of the game that, sure, runs okay (framerate hiccups during cutscenes aside), but has new bugs (didn’t even mention the possibility of just falling through the floor), looks worse, and can’t even be bothered to make new screenshots for the in-game snapshots attached to objectives, which are now all replaced by one movie still for all objectives per level. A photo mode is in this game already; I could take half of these pictures in-game myself!

Yellow frog enemies
I frogot about the quality of the frogs in this game, they’re pretty good!

As the competition for licensed game rereleases grows, the more unacceptable these kinds of efforts become. Perhaps back in the day I could make an argument that, if nothing else, at least the game’s able to be played on modern systems, but now, a studio that on average puts more effort into even worse games could have done this better. This isn’t even the original release, and there’s no way to make it look anything like it! The graphical options are limited to enabling antialiasing, changing the shadow quality, and distance clipping.

You’re not re-examining the original because it’s too different in look and feel; you’re not coming back to it with new context or any extra information, as there are no bonuses to speak of. The co-op requires an Epic Account on Steam, and after playing the first level to test the game, I could not force my younger sibling to play it with me locally, knowing just how bad the game feels. Who knows, maybe the new designs would also give her nightmares.

A prisoner with his hands in fists up high and mouth wide open
Pictured: me after I finished the game and was free to stop playing

My lonely journey continued, and in the moments when the music cut out completely (this happened often), in silence, I pondered my life choices. Do I still hold genuine love for these dumb licensed games, or was this just one bad release? So I fired up the original to check and, sure enough, it’s the latter. This is a really, really bad release; it’s like a fake memory forcefully drilling itself into my head. Truly, even games this mid deserve better.

Mateusz played DreamWorks Shrek 2 Remastered on PC with a provided review code. This review is based on the version of the game available at the time of writing and our score will not be changed.

Score
2/10 Dire - GameObserver Doesn't Recommend
Summary

Mateusz says: "An unacceptable effort in a year with much better ports and remasters of licensed games, DreamWorks Shrek 2 Remastered is not a hit of nostalgia—it's a hit in the gut."

More
GameObserver's Review Policy

More on these topics:

Observe With Us

Stay in the Game

Get the latest reviews, features and news delivered straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Leave a Comment

ObserverCrew Picks

More From FilmObserver and RetroObserver